There’s something about a Sunday pot roast that feels like the ultimate comfort food. Tender beef that’s been slowly cooked until it falls apart, rich pan juices, and deeply caramelized onions are hard to beat on their own. But pile all of that onto a freshly baked Japanese milk bun with a generous spread of homemade garlic aioli, and you’ve got an entirely different way to enjoy a classic.
This Sunday Pot Roast Sandwich takes everything I love about a traditional pot roast and turns it into a seriously good sandwich. The beef is cooked low and slow until it can easily be pulled apart, while the onions are caramelized until sweet and jammy. A garlicky aioli cuts through all that richness, and the homemade Japanese milk buns are incredibly soft and fluffy while still being sturdy enough to hold everything together.
It’s the kind of sandwich worth making the pot roast for—but it’s also one of the best things you can do when you have leftover roast sitting in the fridge.
What will you need?
For the pot roast
- chuck roast
- salt
- sweet onion
- garlic
- celery
- carrots
- avocado oil
- pepper
- fennel seeds
- oregano
- tomato paste
- red wine
- better than beef bouillon
- beef stock
- baby potatoes
- fresh rosemary
- fresh thyme
- fresh bay leaves
For the Caramelized onions and mushrooms
- sweet onions
- portabella muschrooms
- salt
- pepper
- avocado oil
- Worcestershire sauce
For the aioli
- egg
- vegetable oil
- lemon juice
- horseradish cream
- dijon mustard
- garlic
- salt
- pepper
For serving
- your favorite buns. If you want to make the Japanese Milk Buns I used in the video, see recipe here.
- Giardiniera
- provolone cheese
How to make it
Make the pot roast
Salt all side of the chuck roast. Add the avocado oil to a Dutch oven over high heat. Once the oil starts to smoke, lay in the chuck roast. Sear on both sides until a nice crust forms. about 2-3 minutes per side. Remove to a plate.
Reduce the heat to medium and add in the onion and celery. Mix in 1 tsp of salt and the pepper. Sauté until the onions are soft and translucent. About 7-10 minutes. Mix in the garlic, fennel seeds, and oregano. Sauté for 1 minute. Mix in the tomato paste and cook out for 30 seconds. Pour in the wine and cook out for 2 minutes. Mix in the better than beef bouillon.
Add back in the beef. Pour in the beef stock, and add in the carrots. Tie the rosemary, thyme, and bay leaves together with butcher twine and add to the pot. Add in the potatoes. Cover and put in a 275F oven for 6-8 hours or until the meat is very tender.
Remove from the oven and let cool for 20 minutes. Remove the rosemary, thyme, and bay leaves and discard. Remove the beef to a bowl and shred. Strain the braising liquid into another bowl. Add the potatoes and carrots from the strainer into the shredded beef and mix together. Reserve the braising liquid for dipping.
For the aioli
Add the oil, egg, garlic, lemon juice, dijon mustard, horseradish cream, salt, pepper to a blender cup. Blend using an emersion blender starting at the bottom and slowly working your way to the top. Keep blending until emulsified. If you want the aioli thinner, add 1 tbsp at a time of cold water until you reached your desired consistency.
For the caramelized mushrooms and onions
To a skillet over medium heat add in the avocado oil. Once hot, add in the mushrooms, salt, and pepper, Sauté until they start to caramelize. About 8 minutes. Remove from the pan.
To the same pan, add in the onions. Sauté until they caramelize. About 15-20 minutes. We want these almost to be a jam. Add back in the mushrooms. Mix in the Worcestershire sauce and cook for 2 minutes.
Serve
Butter both sides of a bun and toast in a pan until golden. Place on a serving plate. Spread a layer of the aioli onto the bottom bun. Layer with the caramelized onions and mushrooms, the shredded beef with carrots and potatoes, and giardiniera. Add a slice of provolone cheese and melt using a torch. Add the top bun.
Ladle some of the reserved braising broth to a dipping bowl. Dip you sandwich in the broth and enjoy!





